Provider profile

My Critter Pro

4.9 stars from 55 customer reviews · 53 E Jeffrey Pl, Columbus, OH 43214

  • 4.9 out of 5 stars
  • 55 customer reviews
  • Columbus, Ohio
  • Open 7 days, Early hours, Evening hours
4.9
Rating
55
Reviews
Yes
Claimed
Yes
Website

About this provider in Columbus

My Critter Pro offers top-tier wildlife control and pest control services in Columbus, Ohio, and surrounding areas. We specialize in bat, mouse, raccoon, rodent, squirrel, and groundhog removal through comprehensive animal exclusion and trapping services. Don't know what's in your attic? No problem. We will diagnose…

Pests handledbatsmy critter promolesskunkbirds
Praised forknowledgeableprofessionaldiligentreliable
Methodsmy critter proone way traps
Safetyprecautionssafely

Rating breakdown from customer reviews

4.9

55 reviews

5
54
4
0
3
0
2
1
1
0

Customer reviews for My Critter Pro

RE

RJ Edmonds (S)

6mo ago

Jim and Anthony were great to work with when we had a skunk move in under our front porch! They were upfront about costs, responsive to our texts and calls, and professional from start to finish. Highly recommended!

SS

Susan Schultz

9mo ago

My Critter Pro provided A+ high quality service from start to finish in helping to eradicate moles from our yard. Jim is professional, extremely knowledgeable, and diligent. Highly recommend!

AT

Amy Thompson

11mo ago

My critter pro was awesome! I had a bat in my house after getting some gutter/fascia work done. I called at 9pm and was able to actually speak to someone (I called 2 other 24/7 companies also and got nothing). He came out the next morning, got the bat, inspected my home for entry points, and gave honest recommendations on what he was seeing. Didn’t try to up-charge me for precautions I didn’t need. Hopefully I won’t need there servicing again, but if I do, will absolutely call My Critter Pros.

Provider response

Thank you for writing about your experience, Amy. I am glad we were able to safely remove the bat from your home. We are always here for you should you need us in the future!

NE

Noah Eblin

11mo ago

We called Jim and Anthony from MyCritterPro when we heard raccoons running around in our attic and had an exterior vent ripped open. They were able to come out that day, as opposed to most companies which would be a couple days to a week out. They were able to trap the raccoon over night, check the trap and retrieve the critter, and do it one more time the next morning. After that they checked inside to make sure there wasn’t any damage or disruption from the critters, and sealed everything up and replaced the vent. They were extremely timely, accommodating, communicative, transparent, and fair. Would definitely work with them again but hope I don’t need to!

Provider response

Thanks for your review, Noah. We are always here if you need us, but we hope you never do!

JL

Jamie Lee

11mo ago

We heard a critter (I suspect a bat) trapped in our walls. Jim came out to inspect our house. Upon evidence of bats in the attic, he set up one way traps to evacuate them safely and sealed up all potential entry points. Jim was respectful, professional and reliable. He was very pleasant to deal with and I would recommend him to family and friends.

Provider response

Jamie, thank you for the 5 star review. We enjoyed working with you as well

BL

Brendan Leonard

1y ago

We had a bat in the house. I called and they came out shortly after. I called 5 different companies for quotes and theirs came out the lowest. I know you shouldn’t automatically take the lowest bidder but I checked reviews and it seemed they had a good reputation. And I’m glad I did, they were AWESOME! The bat was in a tricky spot, a crevice in the basement floor and they worked their magic. Definitely going to recommend to anyone that has issues with wildlife getting into their homes, I love wildlife but not inside :)

Provider response

Hi Brendan, we pride ourselves on affordable prices and always try to get to everyone within 24 hours. Thank you for reviewing our services.

FS

Fred Santopadre

1y ago

They were quick, efficient and priced accordingly. I would definitely recommend too all in need.

Provider response

Thank you for the 5 star review!

SP

Sarah Priebe

1y ago

I highly recommend My Critter Pro! Jim, the owner, handled our issue himself, and it truly shows in the quality, care, and professionalism he brings to the process. From the first time I text to set up and appointment, Jim was prompt, thorough, and incredibly knowledgeable. He took the time to explain everything clearly, identified the issue quickly, and provided a humane and effective solution (which was also safe for our dogs). You can tell he genuinely cares-- not just about solving the problem, but about doing it right and making sure your home is protected long-term. I would definitely hire again but hope I never have to ;)

Provider response

Thank you for leaving a review! We were happy to help with your mice issue.

CH

Ceselee Hendricks

1y ago

Jim is great! We called in a panic because we were ghosted by another company for a birds nest removal job and Jim and his team were able to come right away! Super nice guy and went above and beyond to clean up the mess the birds left and educated us on how to prevent them from coming again. Will absolutely use My Critter Pro in the future!

Provider response

We were happy to help you remove the bird nest material so you could complete your masonry project!

SL

Shannon Langella

1y ago

We unexpectedly found out that we had bats when getting our roof replaced, which was obviously stressful. Jim from My Critter Pro was able to come out same day to do a thorough inspection. He was calm and matter of fact, and took a lot of time explaining everything to us. Due to a cancellation he was actually able to come out the following day to do the exclusion, which was amazing. His pricing was in line with other quotes we received, and his communication about when he would arrive was above & beyond. Thanks to them we are now bat free! Highly recommend.

Provider response

Thanks for the kind review, Shannon. It was a pleasure to help!

JK

John Kontz

1y ago

My racoon issues were resolved in the less than 24 hours.l highly recommend My Critter Pro

WH

Wendi Henderhan

1y ago

Jim and Anthony came out first thing Monday morning to address a Mouse that had gotten in from a poorly sealed dryer vent.These guys were complete pros. They provided friendly, thorough service at a very fair price. I have already recommended them to two friends in the event that they ever have a problem. Don’t call anyone else call Jim!

BG

Billy Ginley

1y ago

I had a great experience with My Critter Pro and Jim. He came out same day on a Friday and was honest with his quote. He was great with follow up as well, making sure he fixed the problem long term instead of just temporarily. Would recommend anyone looking for this kind of service in Columbus reach out to Jim.

PC

Paula Corpus

1y ago

First let me say that I highly recommend Jim and My Critter Pro. A friend of ours recommended My Critter Pro, and I was very pleased with the entire experience. When I called Jim, originally he told me that they couldn't come out until Friday, but today Jim contacted me and let me know they had a cancellation and that they could come out earlier. When Jim and his partner came out they did a thorough inspection. They both were very professional and courteous, and they took time to put on shoe covers before they came into my house. After they inspected our attic, they showed us pictures of the squirrel they saw and they made some recommendations for what we could do to get rid of the squirrel. We really appreciated how honest and helpful they were. They even gave us suggestions for how we could get rid of the squirrel ourselves and save money. I would definitely call Jim, My Critter Pro again for help with critter removal. I would also feel good about recommending My Critter Pro to my family, friends and neighbors!

AK

Andrew Kuehn

1y ago

Can’t say enough good things about Jim. Woke up after our first night with our newborn on a weekend to a raccoon problem and he came out the same day. Quick, honest and fair pricing. Helped us diagnose our issue and spent time answering all of my questions. Will always recommend My Critter Pro.

MC

Mitchell Crompton

1y ago

Jim helped me with a racoon problem in my house. With his expertise, he was able to find out how they were getting in, trap and remove to prevent this issue from happening in the future. Very trustworthy, knowledgeable, and dependable. I highly suggest calling Jim for all of your pest control needs. He went above and beyond to help my situation!

Provider response

Thank you for the 5 star review!

Other providers in Columbus worth comparing

Pest control near Columbus compare other Ohio markets

Back to all Columbus exterminators or the full Ohio directory.

Treatment and cost guides before you call

Ratings and reviews are sourced from public Google Business Profile data and reflect the date they were collected. They are not verified by this site and may change. This site is free to use. We may be paid by the companies listed here when you call or submit a request, which can affect where and how they appear. We are not a pest control provider and do not endorse, warrant, or guarantee any company's work, licensing, or pricing — always verify those directly.