Pest Control in Neenah, WI
4 exterminators serving 1 zip codes. Average rating: 4.83 stars from 236 reviews.
Providers
4
Avg Rating
4.83 ★
Reviews
236
Zip Codes
1
What Customers Mention Most
Review Insights for Neenah, WI
🐛 Common Pests
👍 What Customers Love
🔧 Treatment Methods
⏱ Response Times Mentioned
Recent Reviews in Neenah
Had a technician come today at my new apartment. He took the only key to my apartment as well as leaving my place unlocked when he left. Maintenance staff contacted the company but they pretty much just sided with their technician. I don’t know about anyone else but it seems kinda creepy knowing there’s some technician out there with a key to my place. I won’t be staying there until new locks are installed. I’m waiting for camera footage to load up to see if he did more than just take a key. So
If you're looking for a small local business with great customer service, I highly recommend Nuisance Pro. WAY better than the big companies in the area. Nathan was amazing. He spent hours outside in the cold rain, sleet and snow trying to find the smallest hole for mice to get through and into our attic. He was patient and kind with my two little boys who were so excited to be a part of what he was doing. He came out the same day which I deeply appreciated and the cost was extremely reason
Great experience! Heard scratching in the walls/ceiling and it seemed the critter had no way out, and would likely die in the wall if we left it. Nathan was friendly and realistic with our options and headed over right away -- even though his day was already booked, he found time to squeeze us in on his way to another job. He certainly didn't have to, but he was willing to make it work. Nathan did great inspecting the situation and safely removing the bird. In comparison, I called around to mul
Owner Response
That bird was in big trouble, glad we saved it! Thank you for this wonderful review. Nathan
I had a wasp nest and posted on the Next Door app. Garrett's wife responded that her husband, Garrett takes care of that problem! I called them up, set up an appointment, and it has been a week since he came over, and no more wasps! He came over at the appointment time, was friendly and efficient. It was way cheaper than Wil Kil and half the price of the Bee Guy. Very satisfied with the work. Thanks again, Garrett!
Kyle was my service tech and a pleasure to work with. He contacts me before coming, so I can communicate areas of problems or any concerns I may have. He is very willing to address those areas and does a great job treating my property. The company as a whole works to make scheduling and payments easy, and they are willing to work with me on times and dates when needed. I would recommend this company.
Owner Response
Thank you!
We had evidence of mice in the attic so we had nuisance pros come out and take a look. Nathan was very professional and very thorough in evaluating the home and where they could be getting in. He gave us tips on how to take care of the issue. He gave us a quote to come out and seal it, but also gave us the information so we could do it ourselves as we have done similar house projects in the past.
Owner Response
Happy to help Steve and thank you for the kind review. Nathan
Top Pest Control Companies in Neenah
At 1st Choice Pest Control, we know that each home is unique. As a locally-owned company, 1st Choice Pest Control is committed to providing you with quality service and delivering total pest protection in the Neenah, WI area. We specialize in protection against common pests, including Insects, Roden
“Had a technician come today at my new apartment. He took the only key to my apartment as well as leaving my place unlocked when he left. Maintenance staff contacted the company but they pretty much just sided with their technician. I don’t know about anyone else but it seems kinda creepy knowing there’s some technician out there with a key to my place. I won’t be staying there until new locks are installed. I’m waiting for camera footage to load up to see if he did more than just take a key. So ”
Professional animal removal service specializing in bats, birds and nuisance wildlife! Serving the Fox Valley and Surrounding Areas. Nuisance Pro is a member of the Wisconsin Trappers Association. Family owned and operated professional animal control services. Common Situations: Animals making noi
“If you're looking for a small local business with great customer service, I highly recommend Nuisance Pro. WAY better than the big companies in the area. Nathan was amazing. He spent hours outside in the cold rain, sleet and snow trying to find the smallest hole for mice to get through and into our attic. He was patient and kind with my two little boys who were so excited to be a part of what he was doing. He came out the same day which I deeply appreciated and the cost was extremely reason”

Since 1991, Garrett Maintenance Services has been Fox Valley clients’ source for professional commercial and residential cleaning services. We are an A+ BBB Accredited Business servicing the Fox Valley area. Our services include janitorial services, carpet and floor cleaning, window cleaning, reside
“I had a wasp nest and posted on the Next Door app. Garrett's wife responded that her husband, Garrett takes care of that problem! I called them up, set up an appointment, and it has been a week since he came over, and no more wasps! He came over at the appointment time, was friendly and efficient. It was way cheaper than Wil Kil and half the price of the Bee Guy. Very satisfied with the work. Thanks again, Garrett!”
Service Area — 1 Zip Codes
Pest Control Costs in Neenah
Typical pest control pricing for Neenah, Wisconsin:
One-Time
$150–$500 depending on pest type and home size
Quarterly
$100–$300 per quarter
Termite
$500–$2,500+ depending on treatment type and home size
Pest Season in Neenah, WI
Cold winters with heavy snow limit outdoor pest activity but drive rodents, cockroaches, and other pests indoors for extended periods. Peak season: May through September.
Spring
As snow melts, carpenter ants and wasps emerge from dormancy — inspect eaves and wood structures.
Summer
Short but intense pest season; treat yards early and keep up with mosquito prevention.
Fall
Fall invasions happen fast — seal the home before the first hard freeze.
Winter
Long winters mean months of indoor rodent pressure; use bait stations and traps proactively.
When to Call an Exterminator in Neenah
- Recurring pests despite DIY treatments
- Termite evidence (mud tubes, damaged wood, swarmers)
- Bed bugs — professional treatment is the only reliable solution
- Large cockroach infestation (seeing roaches during the day)
- Wasps or hornets nesting near living areas
- Wildlife in attic or crawlspace (raccoons, bats, squirrels)
Get Free Quotes in Neenah
Get Free Pest Control Quotes in Neenah, Wisconsin
Compare providers and pricing. No obligation.
Frequently Asked Questions
How many pest control companies are in Neenah, WI?
There are 4 pest control companies serving Neenah, Wisconsin, covering 1 zip codes. The average rating is 4.83 stars from 236 total reviews.
What is the best pest control company in Neenah?
Based on ratings and review volume, 1st Choice Pest Control is the top-rated pest control company in Neenah with 4.9 stars from 189 reviews. Other highly rated options include Nuisance Pro, LLC (4.7 stars).
What pests are common in Neenah, WI?
Based on customer reviews, the most reported pests in Neenah are mice, rodents, dead bird, the critter, baby bird. Local exterminators can help identify and treat these and other pests in your area.
What zip codes are covered in Neenah?
Pest control providers in Neenah cover 1 zip code: 54956.
How much does pest control cost in Neenah?
Pest control costs in Neenah vary by service: one-time treatments typically run $150–$500 depending on pest type and home size, quarterly plans $100–$300 per quarter per visit, and termite treatments $500–$2,500+ depending on treatment type and home size. Get multiple quotes from providers listed above for accurate local pricing.
When is pest season in Neenah, WI?
Peak pest season in the Neenah area runs May through September. Cold winters with heavy snow limit outdoor pest activity but drive rodents, cockroaches, and other pests indoors for extended periods. Year-round quarterly service is recommended for consistent protection.