What customers mention most in New Windsor
Review signals
Review Insights for New Windsor, NY
Common Pests
What Customers Love
Common Complaints
Treatment Methods
Response Times
Recent review proof
Recent review proof from New Windsor
I was initially very optimistic about working with this company. They are highly rated, and the customer service on initial contact and timing to appointment was very good. Unfortunately it fell apart when they sent the technician. The technician they sent only spoke Spanish, and I unfortunately only speak English so there was a major language barrier. His translator that he was trying to use was not working and we simply could not communicate. I felt bad for him, but I unfortunately had to send
Owner Response
I'm sorry to hear about your experience with the language barrier during the service appointment. Jose is a great technician and goes above and beyond. We understand the frustration this situation may have caused, and we apologize for the inconvenience. Please feel free to contact us for futher assi
We are quite pleased with the service call by Rob D. From Hollenbeck Pest Control today. Rob was early for our appointment, pleasant and very knowledgeable. This was our first experience with a pesky mouse and he explained the steps to take to prevent any further unwelcome critter visits. Rob came to assess the situation but was then able to service our issue. At this time we feel more comfortable in our home and welcome the follow-ups. Hollenbeck was recommended to us and now we highly reco
Owner Response
Thank you Ms. Mattera for the 5-star review. We are pleased to read that your experience and service made you feel more comfortable in your home. We will pass your kind words onto Rob.
I'm very pleased with the knowledge and professionalism of the technician. He complied with all my requests. Very good job Mike. I'm thoroughly impressed with Max. In fact I'm so impressed with his work ethics and demeanor i am requesting him for future treatments. He did an awesome job (May 2, 2024). He listened to and respected my needs. Max came by today (5/29/25) to apply treatment to my home. Again, I'm thoroughly impressed with his work ethics and thoughtfulness. He advised us on what t
Owner Response
Thank you Roger! We value your review and will let Mike know your positive experience with him.
Featured providers in New Windsor
Hollenbeck Pest Control
273 Quassaick Ave, New Windsor, NY 12553
Hollenbeck Pest Control, established in 2007 and family-owned, provides guaranteed pest control services in the Greater Hudson Valley. Our team of experts specializes in residential and commercial exterminations, offering solutions for a wide range of pests, including insects, rodents, termites, bed
4.9 out of 5
793 reviews
First Rate Pest Solutions
2391 NY-32, New Windsor, NY 12553
At First Rate Solutions, we are proud to be one of New York’s premiere pest control companies that has provided superior service to clients for nearly two decades. As a full service company, we provide pro-active pest control solutions and client education to prevent pests from invading your propert
4.8 out of 5
34 reviews
All pest control companies in New Windsor with profile links
| Provider | Rating | Reviews | Phone | Address |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Hollenbeck Pest Control | 4.9 | 793 | (845) 565-5566 | 273 Quassaick Ave, New Windsor, NY 12553 |
| First Rate Pest Solutions | 4.8 | 37 | (845) 534-2229 | 2391 NY-32, New Windsor, NY 12553 |
Service area ZIP codes across New Windsor
Common pest problems in New Windsor treatment and cost guides
Use these guides when you want context on a specific pest before calling a local exterminator in New Windsor.
Other New York pest control cities nearby comparisons
See the full New York pest control directory for every city.
Frequently asked questions for New Windsor
How many pest control companies are listed in New Windsor, NY?
There are 2 pest control companies serving New Windsor, New York. This city page also covers 1 ZIP codes and 827 customer reviews.
How much does pest control cost in New Windsor?
One-time treatments typically run $150–$500 depending on pest type and home size, quarterly plans are often $100–$300 per quarter, and termite work often starts near $500–$2,500+ depending on treatment type and home size. Final pricing depends on the pest type, urgency, and property size.
What should I compare before hiring a company in New Windsor?
Across the 2 companies listed in New Windsor, the useful comparisons are recent review volume, current rating, treatment guarantees, New York licensing status, and response speed. Local customers most often mention technician, bees, inspection.
When is pest season in New Windsor, NY?
Peak pest season in the New Windsor area typically runs April through October. New York's temperate climate with cold winters and warm, humid summers concentrates pest activity into warmer months, though indoor pests persist year-round.
Ratings and reviews are sourced from public Google Business Profile data and reflect the date they were collected. They are not verified by this site and may change. This site is free to use. We may be paid by the companies listed here when you call or submit a request, which can affect where and how they appear. We are not a pest control provider and do not endorse, warrant, or guarantee any company's work, licensing, or pricing — always verify those directly.